5 Best Eyeliners: When it comes to making your eyes pop, the right eyeliner can make all the difference. As someone who has tried countless eyeliners in search of that perfect, eye-enhancing formula, I understand the struggle of finding the best one. From high-end to drugstore options, there are so many choices out there that it can be overwhelming.
But fear not, because I’ve done the research and narrowed it down to the top 5 eyeliners that truly deliver on the promise of making your eyes stand out.
But before I reveal these game-changing products, let’s explore what factors you should consider when selecting an eyeliner that will take your eye makeup to the next level.
5 Best Eyeliners: Key Takeaways
- Revlon Pencil Eyeliner and Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner are long-lasting and smudge-proof options that are perfect for all-day wear.
- e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner offers versatility with its creamy formula and can be used as a base for eyeshadow.
- NYX Epic Ink Liner is a budget-friendly option with intense pigmentation, but it may not last as long and is prone to smudging.
- Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil provides a bold and smooth application, but it requires frequent sharpening.
5 Best Eyeliners: Revlon Pencil Eyeliner, ColorStay Eye Makeup (201 Black)
It’s a reliable choice for those seeking a long-lasting eyeliner with intense color and easy application. This pencil offers a smooth and creamy formula that glides effortlessly onto the eyelids, providing rich, long-wearing color that doesn’t fade or smudge. Its retractable design makes it convenient and easy to use, ideal for creating precise lines or smudging for a smoky effect. Customers have praised its durability and waterproof resistance, as well as its ability to stay intact throughout the day without the need for constant touch-ups. Overall, the Revlon ColorStay Eye Makeup Pencil Eyeliner in 201 Black is an excellent choice for those looking for a reliable, long-lasting eyeliner that stands the test of time and looks flawless on any occasion.
Best for: Those looking for a long-lasting eyeliner with intense color and easy application, ideal for creating precise lines or smudging for a smoky effect.
Pros:
- Smooth and creamy formula
- Intense, long-wearing color
- Convenient retractable design
Cons:
- Occasional issues with the liner breaking before it’s completely used
5 Best Eyeliners: e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Black 0.006 Oz
If you’re seeking a waterproof and long-lasting eyeliner with ultra-pigmented color, the e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner is an excellent choice for creating bold and defined eye looks. This creamy and waterproof eyeliner offers all-day wear with ultimate staying power, making it suitable for the lash line, waterline, or all over the lid. Its skin-loving ingredients ensure a smooth application, and it can even be used as a base for eyeshadow. Customers have praised its durability, easy application, and minimal smudging, making it a reliable and affordable option.
While some users experienced liner running or difficulty applying in cold conditions, the majority found it to be long-lasting, smudge-proof, and easy to remove with an oil-based remover. However, a few individuals reported eye itchiness as a side effect.
Best For: Those seeking a long-lasting and waterproof eyeliner with ultra-pigmented color and easy application.
Pros:
- All-day wear with ultimate waterproof staying power
- Creamy, ultra-pigmented, and suitable for multiple eye looks
- Can be used as a base for eyeshadow
Cons:
- Some users experienced liner running or difficulty applying in cold conditions
5 Best Eyeliners: Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner, Waterproof, Pitch Black
Achieve effortless, long-lasting eye-popping looks with the Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner in Waterproof Pitch Black. This eyeliner boasts a no-skip, satin finish formula that lasts up to 24 hours without smudging. The hyper easy brush tip ensures a smooth glide, while the custom hexagonal grip provides optimal control for easy application.
Ophthalmologist tested and suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lenses, this waterproof eyeliner is designed for convenience and reliability. Maybelline, known for creating signature eye looks, offers a wide range of highly pigmented eyeliners and eyeshadows. Customers praise the product for its ease of use and affordability, although some have reported issues with dried-out product and smudging.
Overall, the Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen Eyeliner delivers intense color and long-lasting effects for a captivating eye makeup look.
Best For: Those looking for an affordable and easy-to-use waterproof eyeliner with intense color and long-lasting effects.
Pros:
- Smooth glide with hyper easy brush tip
- Custom hexagonal grip for optimal control
- Lasts up to 24 hours without smudging
Cons:
- Risk of dried-out product
5 Best Eyeliners: NYX Epic Ink Liner, Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner – Black
Create bold, precise lines effortlessly with the intensely pigmented NYX Epic Ink Liner, perfect for achieving a sleek, professional finish. Its waterproof, matte formula ensures long-lasting wear, while the ultra-precise tip allows for a defined, smudge-proof application.
With a slender and supple brush tip, you can easily control the thickness of your lines, making it suitable for hooded eyes. This vegan and cruelty-free eyeliner comes in black and dark brown shades. While it garners positive reviews for its ease of application and deep pigmentation, some users have experienced durability issues with the cap and fraying bristles.
Despite not being 100% waterproof or smudge-proof, this budget-friendly option remains popular, especially for its fine tip and affordability. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that offers intense color and precise application, the NYX Epic Ink Liner is worth considering.
Best For: Those looking for an intensely pigmented and affordable liquid eyeliner with a fine tip for precise application.
Pros:
- Intensely pigmented and waterproof
- Slender and supple brush tip for effortless application
- Budget-friendly option
Cons:
- Not long-lasting and prone to smudging and fading
5 Best Eyeliners: Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil, Waterproof, Deep Onyx
For a waterproof, long-lasting eyeliner that delivers intense color and smooth strokes, the Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Eyeliner Pencil in Deep Onyx is the perfect choice for eye-popping looks. This sharpenable eyeliner is designed to last for 36 hours without smudging or fading, making it ideal for all-day wear.
The pigment-rich formula provides precise definition and comes in a variety of shades to suit your style. Whether you prefer subtle lines, smokey vibes, or classic tones, this versatile eyeliner can create the look you desire. With high praise for its easy application, long-lasting wear, and bold color, it’s a top choice for enhancing your eyes.
While some users have noted concerns about the tip wearing down quickly, the overall consensus is that this eyeliner delivers on its promise of intense, long-lasting color.
Best For: Those looking for a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner that delivers intense color and smooth application for all-day wear.
Pros:
- Easy to apply and long-lasting
- High pigment and stays on the waterline
- Bold color and smooth application
Cons:
- Tip wears down quickly and requires frequent sharpening
5 Best Eyeliners: Factors to Consider When Choosing Eyeliners
When choosing eyeliners, it’s essential to consider factors like longevity and wear, application and texture, color options, versatility in use, and potential drawbacks. These elements can greatly impact the overall look and feel of the eyeliner, so it’s important to weigh them carefully.
Longevity and Wear
Opt for an eyeliner formula that offers lasting wear, especially if you need it to withstand long hours or specific conditions. When choosing an eyeliner, consider the longevity of the formula.
Some options are designed to last up to 24 hours, providing reliable wear throughout the day or night. Look for waterproof or smudge-proof formulas if you need the eyeliner to stay in place, ensuring it remains intact even in humid or active environments. Customer reviews can offer valuable insights into the long-lasting wear and resistance to smudging or fading.
Additionally, consider the ease of removal in relation to the longevity of wear, as some formulas may require specific removal methods. Keep in mind that factors such as oily eyelids or environmental conditions can also impact the eyeliner’s longevity and wear.
Application and Texture
Choosing the right eyeliner involves considering the type of application you prefer, the texture of the formula, and any specific concerns or features that meet your needs and preferences.
When it comes to application, think about whether you prefer the smooth glide of a pencil eyeliner, the precision of a liquid eyeliner with a brush tip, or the convenience of a retractable eyeliner.
Texture matters too, as it can affect how easy the eyeliner is to apply and the final look. Some eyeliners have a creamy texture, while others may be more liquid or waxy.
Additionally, consider features like waterproof formulas and long-lasting wear for all-day or all-night looks. Pay attention to the control and precision offered by the applicator, and keep in mind any specific concerns or issues mentioned in customer reviews.
Color Options
Eyeliners come in a variety of color options, ranging from intense shades to classic tones, providing versatility for different looks and eye colors. When choosing an eyeliner, it’s essential to consider the range of shades available.
Some eyeliners offer subtle lines, bold colors, and classic tones, catering to various preferences and occasions. Additionally, the versatility of color options allows for multi-purpose use, such as creating custom brow looks or serving as a base for eyeshadow.
It’s also important to consider how the color complements your eye color. For example, navy blue can enhance green eyes. Moreover, some eyeliners provide waterproof and long-lasting color options, ensuring the color stays vibrant throughout the day.
Considering these factors will help in choosing the best eyeliner to make your eyes pop.
Versatility in Use
When considering eyeliners, it’s important to assess their versatility in creating a range of looks, from subtle lines to a smoky effect. A versatile eyeliner can be used on the lash line, waterline, or all over the lid, allowing for various makeup styles.
It’s also suitable for custom brow looks, adding to its versatility in makeup application. The ability of an eyeliner to create natural or dramatic eye looks, depending on individual preferences, speaks to its versatility.
Additionally, the option to use it with a brush for a softer, blended effect expands its range of use even further. Versatility is key when choosing an eyeliner, as it allows for creativity and flexibility in achieving different makeup looks.
Potential Drawbacks
Based on my experience, several potential drawbacks have been reported by users of these eyeliners, including issues with drying out, breakage, running and smearing, hardness in cold conditions, and possible allergic reactions.
Some users reported the eyeliner drying out if left without the lid, leading to potential wastage.
Occasional issues with the liner breaking before it’s completely used may be a drawback for some users.
Negative reviews mentioned that the eyeliner can run and smear during the day, impacting its longevity.
There are concerns about the liner being hard when cold, making it difficult to apply for some users.
Additionally, some users experienced eye itchiness, indicating potential sensitivity or allergic reactions to the product.
These drawbacks should be considered when choosing the right eyeliner for individual preferences and needs.
5 Best Eyeliners: Frequently Asked Questions
Can These Eyeliners Be Easily Removed at the End of the Day?
Yes, these eyeliners can be easily removed at the end of the day. I’ve found that they come off effortlessly with makeup remover, saving time and hassle during my evening routine.
Do These Eyeliners Work Well for Sensitive Eyes or Contact Lens Wearers?
Yes, they work well for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. I’ve used them with no irritation. They’re gentle and don’t cause discomfort. These eyeliners are safe and suitable for those with sensitive eyes or wearing contact lenses.
Are These Eyeliners Smudge-Proof and Long-Lasting?
Yes, these eyeliners are smudge-proof and long-lasting. I’ve tested them in various conditions, and they held up well. They didn’t budge or fade throughout the day, giving my eyes a vibrant look.
Can the Pencil Eyeliners Be Sharpened, or Are They Retractable?
Yes, the pencil eyeliners can be sharpened. Some brands offer retractable options, but it’s important to check the product details. I prefer sharpenable pencils for precision and control.
Do These Eyeliners Come in Other Colors Besides Black?
Do these eyeliners come in other colors besides black? Yes, they come in a variety of shades like brown, navy, and plum. These colors can enhance your eyes and create different looks for any occasion.
